My theory about Anna
Nov. 16th, 2008 02:36 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
raloriaI finished capping 4x09 just now (651 caps! Phew!) and a new theory popped into my head. I'm rarely right about these things, so take this however you will. Kripke knows all, not me. :)
Okay, I came to that scene near the end where Sam tells Anna that her parents were dead. Maybe it's just me, but her grief seemed a little...overblown. Overacted, perhaps? I wasn't buying it. It seemed fake. You put that with the fact that her parents were killed by a demon, she has some psychic powers, and she can hear the angels talking and I'm thinking she's one of the YED's special kids like Sam. Btw, I know I'm not the first to think this, but I'm now putting all the pieces together.
Why else would the angels want her dead? 'Cause she's a demon who can hear them. Why would the demons want her alive? 'Cause she can hear the enemy talking and she has powers they can utilize. It just makes sense that if the YED was responsible for her powers that they would manifest, she'd kill her parents, and assuming she's working for Lilith, get on the boys's radar....via Ruby. Ruby broke out of hell, didn't kill Sam as we were shown in the flashbacks, so it would make sense that Lilith would know this and be gunning for her as well. And sure, Anna could know about Samhain and the rising of the Witnesses....if she was a demon in on the breaking of the seals. I also find it a little odd that Anna can see the real faces of demons. Who else but a demon, or in Dean's case, someone on their way to Hell, would be able to do that?
Sure, there's some holes in my theory. The main one being why wouldn't Ruby realize who Anna really is, if she's got demonic tendencies? I still can't answer that one. All I know is that a lot of the other pieces do fit and that's enough to make me very suspicious of her. I'm also wondering how on earth she and Dean end up doing it in the Impala (assuming they are in the car)? There really wasn't much of a build up to any kind of relationship in 4x09, so how do they end up there? Not that I'm against Dean finally getting some onscreen action! We haven't had a Dean sex scene since the first season! They owe us! :)
Like I said, I'm sure I'm wrong about all this. I always am. Kripke's the master and I'm just trying to get inside the guy's evil mind. Based on my lousy scorecard I haven't been able to break through yet. Doesn't mean I won't keep trying though. ;)
Okay, I came to that scene near the end where Sam tells Anna that her parents were dead. Maybe it's just me, but her grief seemed a little...overblown. Overacted, perhaps? I wasn't buying it. It seemed fake. You put that with the fact that her parents were killed by a demon, she has some psychic powers, and she can hear the angels talking and I'm thinking she's one of the YED's special kids like Sam. Btw, I know I'm not the first to think this, but I'm now putting all the pieces together.
Why else would the angels want her dead? 'Cause she's a demon who can hear them. Why would the demons want her alive? 'Cause she can hear the enemy talking and she has powers they can utilize. It just makes sense that if the YED was responsible for her powers that they would manifest, she'd kill her parents, and assuming she's working for Lilith, get on the boys's radar....via Ruby. Ruby broke out of hell, didn't kill Sam as we were shown in the flashbacks, so it would make sense that Lilith would know this and be gunning for her as well. And sure, Anna could know about Samhain and the rising of the Witnesses....if she was a demon in on the breaking of the seals. I also find it a little odd that Anna can see the real faces of demons. Who else but a demon, or in Dean's case, someone on their way to Hell, would be able to do that?
Sure, there's some holes in my theory. The main one being why wouldn't Ruby realize who Anna really is, if she's got demonic tendencies? I still can't answer that one. All I know is that a lot of the other pieces do fit and that's enough to make me very suspicious of her. I'm also wondering how on earth she and Dean end up doing it in the Impala (assuming they are in the car)? There really wasn't much of a build up to any kind of relationship in 4x09, so how do they end up there? Not that I'm against Dean finally getting some onscreen action! We haven't had a Dean sex scene since the first season! They owe us! :)
Like I said, I'm sure I'm wrong about all this. I always am. Kripke's the master and I'm just trying to get inside the guy's evil mind. Based on my lousy scorecard I haven't been able to break through yet. Doesn't mean I won't keep trying though. ;)
